The Lisa McPherson Files have a new home: That site offers additional files and background information; it's also much better organized.

The Lisa McPherson Files - Investigative Report, Cabana Guests, Andrea Catt

This summarizes ongoing investigative activities, including contacting other guests at the cabanas at the Fort Harrison, as well as Andrea Catt.

FL0520300/Clearwater Police Department            Report No.         95-29158
Offense           Death                          Date of Report      4/15/97
Location          644 Pierce Street              Orig Incident Date  12/6/95
Victim            Lisa McPherson                 VI Prosecute        Yes X No
Investigator      Jorge Carrasquillo
Previous Status   Active
Subject           None
Impound Inventory None


Monday, Apri1 14, 1997

On April 14, 1997, I had telephone conversations with the following individuals:
            1. Tony Hitchman: Hitchman said he stayed at the cabanas from the
                middle of November, 1995 until January, 1996. Hitchman said he was at
                the church for services. Hitchman stated he did not see or hear anything
                unusual during his stay. Hitchman has no knowledge of the Lisa
                McPherson case.
            2. Alan Lake: I spoke with Claudia Lake, Jeffrey Lake's wife. Claudia stated
                her husband Jeff has never stayed at the cabanas at 210 S. Ft. Harrison
                Ave. Claudia stated the Church might of mistaken her husband's
                information for Alan Lakes information. Claudia stated she will have Jeff
                return my call. On April 15, 1997 Jeff Lake called and verified his wife's
                statements. Lake stated he is a Scientologist, however he has never stayed
                at the Fort Harrison.
            3. Paul Peter / Susan Ortner: Paul Ortner identified himself as a 60 year
                old w/m. Ortner stated Susan (his wife) and he stayed at the cabanas
                sometime around November 20, 1995. Ortner stated they do not recall
                seeing security guard(s) assigned to any particular room. Ortner stated

                                                                       Page 1 of 4

SUPPLEMENTICONTINUNATION FL0520300/Clearwater Police Department Report No. 95-29158 Offense Death Investigation Date of Report 4/15/97 they did not notice any unusual activity during their stay, other then David Miscavige was staying at the hotel during the same time. Ortner said as a result security was a little more active then usual. 4. Jim Ross Meskimen: Meskimen identified himself as a w/m born in 1959. Meskimen said he and his wife and her parents were staying at the cabanas around the Thanksgiving weekend of November 1995. Meskimen said no one in his party noticed any unusual activity during their stay. Meskimen said he was glad we were investigating Lisa McPherson's death. 5. Sue Swank: Swank said she was at the cabanas during the beginning of December 1995. Swank stated the only thing she saw out of the ordinary was an old man painting the stairs at the cabanas, and someone falling down them because of the paint wet paint. Swank said she was gone most of time from the hotel. Swank said she would usually leave at 0700 hours and return around 2100 hours. I left telephone messages for Brenda Jones, Jim Norton, and Khonda Andrews to return my phone calls. I made telephone contact with a Gail Huse in Canada who informed me that Mary Ann Broughn was currently in Clearwater, Florida. Huse stated she will advise Broughn to return my call. The telephone number for Joe Kraus has been disconnected there is no new telephone number available. The telephone number for Judith Schwyter is incorrect. On April 14, 1997 at approximately 1700 hours I attempted to contact Schwyter at her residence, with negative results. On April 14, 1997 I made three international calls. The first was to Liliane Eckharter's residence. I made telephone contact with a female. I was informed Liliane Eckharter was not home. I attempted to inform the female to please have Page 2 of 4
SUPPLEMENT/CONTINUATION FL0520300/Clearwater Police Department Report No. 95-29158 Offense Death Investigation Date of Report 4/15/97 Liliane return my call, however because of the language barrier I don't believe I was successful. Both telephone numbers provided for Muriel Lore were not functioning. On April 11, 1997, I was informed by Det. Richard Howard that Andrea Catt had called from England, requesting to speak with one of the investigators handling the Lisa McPherson case. On April 14, 1997, I called Catt at 011-44-1929-421-384. Catt stated she might have some useful information regarding Lisa McPherson. Catt said she had been on the Internet and noticed we were having difficulties finding some witnesses. Catt said there is a reason for us not locating the witnesses. Catt stated she is no longer a Scientologist, however in 1994 she was on Staff in Dorset, England as a Registrar (sales person), collecting moneys for the Church. Catt said she was working for the Bournemouth Mission in Dorset. Catt said during 1993 and 1994 the Poole Police, in Dorset county were investigating The Church of Scientology for financial crimes. Catt said the financial crimes were fraudulent bank loans. Catt stated the Church provided Attorney Peter Hodkin for her interviews in 1993. Catt said Hodkin had prior knowledge of the interviews and told her what to say. Catt stated in July of 1995 the Police wanted to interview Catt again. Catt believes the Church had an insider (Police Officer Rod Hawkins) working at Poole Station, because the Church found out about the up coming interviews. (Catt stated she can not prove Hawkins was working for the Church) Catt stated she was immediately made to disappear by Church orders. Catt said the Office of Special Affairs ordered her and her husband out of the country within twenty four hours. Catt stated she was taken to Denmark so the Police could not interview her. Catt was told there was not enough evidence to extradite her from Denmark. Catt said this was done to thwart the investigation. Catt believes we are facing the same problems as Page 3 of 4
SUPPLEMENT/CONTINUATION FL0520300/Clearwater Police Department Report No. 95-29158 Offense Death Investigation Date of Report 4/15/97 the Poole Police. Catt stated if need be she is willing to testify to what she knows. Catt provided the following information: Andrea Catt W/F XX/XX/XX XXXXX XXXXXXXXXX Rd. Swanage, Dorset England XXX XXX Home Tel. # 011-44-XXXX-XXX-XXX Investigation continues. Ofc. Reporting Det. Jorge Carrasguillo ID No. 630 Case Status Active Date Cleared _____________ Clearance Type Exception Type 1. Arrest 1. Extradition declined 3. Death of Offender Adult Juvenile 2. AR of primary offense, 4. V/W refused to cooperate 2. Exceptional secondary offense, 5. Prosecution declined 3. Unfounded w/o prosecution 6. Juv/No Custody Ofc. Reviewing Date SAO Info Page 4 of 4